The Book of Mormon and View of the Hebrews

378 Primary Sources

Date
Summary
1651

Menasseh Ben Israel says Israelites made it to America and that Jewish customs are found among Native Americans.

1660

Thomas Thorowgood argues that Native Americans are descendants of Israelites.

1775

James Adair writes on the Native Americans; posits their descent from the Lost Tribes.

Dec 12, 1800

Courier of New Hampshire reports Ethan Smith being installed as a pastor in NH on March 12, 1800.

Mar 13, 1802

The Constitutional Telegraphe reports Ethan Smith had Jeffersonian Republican political views.

1806 - 1908

Birth record for Oliver Cowdery gives October 3, 1806, as his birth date.

May 26, 1811

Poultney Church Record indicates Keziah Cowdery, Oliver Cowdery's stepmother, joined the congregation in May 1811.

1816

Elias Boudinot's 1816 book A Star in the West attempts to identify the Native Americans as descendants of the Lost Tribes.

Aug 2, 1818

Poultney Church Records indicate Oliver Cowdery's half-sisters were baptized into the church.

1820

1820 census record for William Cowdery.

Nov 4, 1822

Rutland County Herald announces the publication of the Poultney Gazette, coedited by Ethan Smith.

Nov 23, 1822

New Hampshire Sentinel republishes article noting that Ethan Smith is an editor at the Poultney Gazette (publisher of VOTH).

1823

Ethan Smith in introduction to VOTH outlines the intent of his writing.

Jul 30, 1823

Poultney Gazette indicates VOTH is at press.

Aug 6, 1823

Published copyright notice for View of the Hebrews.

Dec 10, 1823

Poultney Gazette advertises View of the Hebrews.

Dec 17, 1823

Poultney Gazette publishes outline of VOTH.

Dec 23, 1823

Saratoga Sentinel publishes negative reivew of VOTH.

Dec 27, 1823

Boston Recorder reviews VOTH.

Dec 30, 1823

Saratoga Sentinel publishes part two of a negative review of View of the Hebrews.

1824

Literary catalogue from 1824 notes publication of View of the Hebrews.

Jan 7, 1824

Northern Spectator advertises View of the Hebrews.

Jan 14, 1824

Northern Spectator advertises the sale of View of the Hebrews.

Jan 17, 1824

Christian Watchman reviews View of the Hebrews.

Jan 28, 1824

Northern Spectator advertises sale of View of the Hebrews.

Feb 4, 1824

Northern Spectator announces the publication and sale of View of the Hebrews.

Feb 12, 1824

Vermont Gazette advertises VOTH for sale.

Feb 23, 1824

New Hampshire Patriot and State Gazette advertises the sale of View of the Hebrews.

Mar 2, 1824

Saratoga Sentinel publishes Ethan Smith's response to a negative review of View of the Hebrews.

Mar 9, 1824

Ethan Smith concludes response to negative review of View of the Hebrews.

Apr 6, 1824

Author of negative review of VOTH responds to Ethan Smith's rejoinder.

Apr 20, 1824

Ballston Spa Gazette advertises View of the Hebrews.

Jul 24, 1824

Vermont Gazette advertises View of the Hebrews.

Oct 1, 1824

The United States Literary Gazette based in Boston reviews VOTH.

Oct 21, 1824

The National Gazette advertises literary guide that includes View of the Hebrews.

1825

Josiah Priest republishes extracts of View of the Hebrews.

1825

Ethan Smith identifies Quetzalcoatl as Moses.

1825

Alexander Proudfit writes letter expressing endorsement of View of the Hebrews.

1825

Ethan Smith summarizes his arguments for the Indians being descendants of the Lost Tribes.

1825

Ethan Smith discusses "Egyptian hieroglyphics" among the ancient Mexicans.

1825

Introduction to the 2nd edition of VOTH.

1825

Ethan Smith describes the Indians having a "Urim and Thummim."

1825

Ethan Smith sites 2 Esdras 13:40 on the migration of the Ten Tribes.

1825

Ethan Smith summarizes his case for Native Americans being the Lost Tribes.

Feb 4, 1825

Jabez B. Hyde positively recommends the theory in VOTH.

Apr 13, 1825

The Wayne Sentinel lists letters waiting for Lyman Cowdery.

May 1825

Review of VOTH in the Utica Christian Repository.

Oct 11, 1825

Mordecai M. Noah posits that the Lost Tribes made it to America; modern Indians are their descendants.

Jan 3, 1826

Connecticut Herald advertises VOTH.

Feb 7, 1826

Western Recorder advertises View of the Hebrews for sale in Utica, NY.

Jul 18, 1826

Litchfield County Post advertises View of the Hebrews.

Sep 1826

The Christian Magazine publishes article that cites VOTH.

Oct 4, 1826

Charleston Courier advertises View of the Hebrews.

Jan 5, 1827

The Wayne Sentinel mentions letters being held for an "Ethan Smith" in Palmyra, NY.

Jan 13, 1827

Christian Secretary advertises VOTH.

May 30, 1827

Vermont Statesman reports the ordination of Ethan Smith.

Jun 1, 1827

Vermont Chronicle reports Ethan Smith's ordination.

Jul 18, 1827

Lyons Advertiser reports letters are at the post office for an "Ethan Smith".

Aug 4, 1827

Old Colony Memorial advertises sale of VOTH.

Oct 17, 1827

Lyons Advertiser reports letters waiting for Oliver Cowdery and William Cowdery.

1828

Israel Worsley reappropriates material from View of the Hebrews in his 1828 book on the Native Americans.

1828

John Marsh cites Ethan Smith and other authors in favor of the authenticity of the Bible.

Jul 4, 1828

The Wayne Sentinel mentions letters waiting for Lyman Cowdery.

Nov 15, 1828

Religious Intelligencer mentions View of the Hebrews in a review.

1829

Barbara Anne Simon cites VOTH in arguing for the Hebraic Indian theory.

Jan 3, 1829

Western Times cites View of the Hebrews in article.

Aug 1829

The Eclectic Review reviews various books on the Hebraic Indian theory, including View of the Hebrews.

Oct 13, 1829

Vermont Telegraph reports negative review of View of the Hebrews.

Dec 28, 1829

Oliver Cowdery writes to Joseph, mentions he has recently become a printer.

1830

Anonymous author criticizes the theory put forth in VOTH.

Mar 26, 1830

Announcement of selling of the Book of Mormon in the Wayne Sentinel.

Nov 25, 1830

Cleveland Herald mentions Oliver Cowdery; claims he was a printer in the mid-1820s.

Feb 7, 1831

Alexander Campbell says Joseph is the author of the Book of Mormon.

1832

Joseph relates how he moved to Pennsylvania.

1832

JS mentions having translated 116 pages of manuscript that Martin Harris lost.

1832

Constantine Samuel Rafinesque says "Mormonites" were based on the same theory as VOTH; credits JS as author of BOM.

1832

Joseph recalls moving to Palmyra when he was 10 years old.

Oct 10, 1832

Boston Recorder reports that Oliver Cowdery was a printer.

1833

Josiah Priest quotes VOTH in his American Antiquities.

1834

In Mormonism Unvailed E. D. Howe suggests that the Book of Mormon is plagiarized from Solomon Spaulding's manuscript.

1834

Joseph Samuel C. F. Frey cites View of the Hebrews in his discussion of the lost ten tribes.

Sep 7, 1834

Oliver Cowdery says he met JS for the first time on April 5, 1829.

1835

Solomon Bennett positive cites VOTH in his book on the Hebrew language.

1837

Mordecai M. Noah argues that Native Americans descend from the Lost Tribes.

Feb 21, 1837

Saratoga Sentinel advertises lecture on themes in VOTH.

1838

Joseph gives a brief sketch of his early life from ca. 1805-1819.

1838

Joseph relates how he moved to Pennsylvania to avoid persecution.

1838

Joseph reports Moroni's visitation on September 21, 1823.

1838

Joseph relates how he obtained the BOM plates.

1838

Joseph mentions meeting Oliver Cowdery for the first time on April 5, 1829.

1838

Joseph relates the loss of the 116 pages.

Mar 8, 1838

Christian Mirror lists View of the Hebrews in an advertisement for theological books.

1840

James B. Finley cites VOTH in his book on the Wyandott Indians.

1841

William Miller critiques Ethan Smith's interpretation of prophecies in the book of Daniel.

1841

Grant Powers describes Ethan Smith's pastorate in Haverhill, NH.

1841

Asahel Grant voices skepticism towards the theory advanced in VOTH.

Jul 1841

The American Biblical Repository mentions VOTH and its theory; voices skepticism.

Oct 1, 1841

Signs of the Times reports that Ethan Smith is lecturing against William Miller's theories.

Oct 29, 1841

Newspaper article mentions Ethan Smith's theory in brief editorial.

Nov 19, 1841

Boston Recorder announces Ethan Smith is lecturing against William Miller.

Dec 25, 1841

Ethan Smith reviews a book on the Lost Ten Tribes of Israel.

1842

J. B. Turner argues JS is the sole author of the BOM.

1842

James Silk Buckingham quotes VOTH in 1842 book on America.

1842

Zadock Thompson provides history of the town of Poultney, VT; mentions Ethan Smith as pastor.

Apr 1842

Article in The King's College Magazine positively cites VOTH.

Jun 1, 1842

Joseph Smith, as editor of Times and Seasons, publishes extracts of View Of The Hebrews.

1844

Robert B. Lewis quotes both the BOM and VOTH in same publication.

1845

Lucy Mack Smith recalls her family's history of moving.

1845

Lucy Mack Smith recalls JS not being "inclined" to reading books as a young man.

1845

Lucy Mack Smith recalls Oliver Cowdery meeting the Smith family for the first time in the spring of 1829.

1846

1846 publication mentions Ethan Smith's pastorate in Hopkinton, New Hampshire.

1846

Catalogue of books at Union College lists VOTH in its holdings.

1848

James H. Hotchkin mentions Ethan Smith's ministry in Western New York.

Aug 11, 1848

Wisconsin Tribune author cites View of the Hebrews.

1849

John Hayward mentions Ethan Smith's pastorate in Haverhill and Hopkinton, New Hampshire.

Feb 28, 1849

Boston Daily Mail republishes extract from VOTH.

Jun 6, 1849

Boston Investigator mentions Ethan Smith's theory in View of the Hebrews; calls it "fiction."

Sep 3, 1849

Boston Evening Transcript reports the death of Ethan Smith.

Sep 20, 1849

Puritan Recorder reports the death of Ethan Smith.

Dec 19, 1849

Abraham Burnham writes a letter describing Ethan Smith.

1850

Orsamus Turner indicates that Oliver Cowdery was a printer in western New York in the mid 1820s.

1852

William Goddell recounts Ethan Smith attending abolitionist meetings.

1852

Orsamus Turner quotes old resident of Allegany, NY, that Benjamin Franklin Cowdery was a printer.

1852

Mark Doolittle provides biographical sketch of Ethan Smith and his family.

1853

John S. Barry reviews history of Ethan Smith's tenure as pastor in Hanover, MA.

1857

William B. Sprauge gives biographical sketch of Ethan Smith.

1857

Biographical sketch of Ethan Smith.

1859

Lyman Copeland Draper criticizes the theory in View of the Hebrews.

1859

Isaac P. Labagh notes theory in View of the Hebrews, but voices some skepticism.

Apr 23, 1859

Millennial Star republishes an extract from View of the Hebrews.

1861

Peter Jones cites View of the Hebrews in his book on the Ojebway Indians.

Aug 1863

Richard Stephen Charnock cites View of the Hebrews in an article.

May 15, 1866

True Latter-Day Saints' Herald editorial cites VOTH as evidence for the BOM.

1867

Short bio of Ethan Smith as a Dartmouth alumnus.

1869

Davis Emerson unpublished bio of Ethan Smith from circa 1869.

1869

Hiland Paul and Robert Parks describe the Cowdery family history in Rutland County.

Mar 11, 1869

J. G. Hale recounts history of Ethan Smith's pastorate in Poultney; discusses the details of his dismissal from the church.

1870

Dartmouth centennial mentions Ethan Smith and VOTH.

Aug 25, 1870

The New Era cites View of the Hebrews in arguing for the Hebraic Indian theory.

Jul 6, 1871

Argus and Patriot retells the history of Ethan Smith being ordained a pastor of a church in Haverhill, NH.

1872

Henry S. Huntington remarks on Ethan Smith's habit of giving long prayers.

1873

William Blackwood provides biographical entries for both Ethan and Joseph Smith.

1874

I. C. Wellcome mentions Ethan Smith's arguments with William Miller on the Second Coming.

1875

1875 history of Poultney, VT, describes the founding and operation of the press that printed View of the Hebrews.

1875

Joseph Joslin gives brief sketch of Ethan Smith's pastorate in Poultney.

1875

Joseph Joslin gives brief sketch of the records of the Congregational Church in Poultney.

1876

Hubert Howe Bancroft cites VOTH and the BOM in same publication.

1878

W. W. Clayton mentions Ethan Smith's brief pastorate in Pompey, NY.

1879

Nathaniel Bartlett Sylvester gives brief biographical sketch of Ethan Smith.

Feb 10, 1879

John Hulbert Gilbert recalls Oliver Cowdery helping on the printing of the Book of Mormon.

Apr 1879

Charles Chase Lord gives brief overview of Ethan Smith's personality and character.

1880

W. Lang provides brief biographical sketch of Oliver Cowdery.

Jan 7, 1880

M. D. Gilman gives bios of Ethan Smith and JS and discusses the coming forth of the BOM.

1882

Abby Maria Hemenway briefly notes the history of William Cowdery living in Vermont.

1884

Clark Braden claims Sidney Rigdon stole ideas from Ethan Smith via Josiah Priest to write the Book of Mormon.

1884

D. Hamilton Hurd mentions Ethan Smith's brief pastorate in Hanover, MA.

1885

James Constantine Pilling gives bibliographic entry for View of the Hebrews.

Jan 28, 1885

Lorenzo Saunders claims Oliver Cowdery met the Smiths in 1826.

1886

Biographical sketch of Ethan Smith by Ephraim Orcutt Jameson.

1886

H. P. Smith and W. S. Rann provide biographical sketch of Ethan Smith; note his work in printing and editing.

Mar 7, 1887

Lucy Cowdery Young, Oliver's half-sister, gives short biography of Oliver Cowdery; mentions he left for NY in circa 1825 and met the Smiths circa 1829.

Apr 24, 1887

The Cleveland Plain Dealer publishes unsourced claims that JS was influenced by Ethan Smith.

May 1887

Biographical sketch of Oliver Cowdery has him living in Poultney, VT until "about" 1825.

1888

James Grant Wilson and John Fiske provide brief bio of Ethan Smith.

1888

Biography of Joseph Smith in same volume that does a biography of Ethan Smith.

1888

Elijah M. Haines positively quotes View of the Hebrews in support of the Hebraic Indian theory.

1889

Justin Winsor briefly reviews authors who contributed to the Hebraic Indian theory; briefly mentions the Book of Mormon.

Nov 1889

Public Opinion mentions both VOTH and the BOM in an article on the Hebraic Indian theory.

1890

J. L. Merrill discusses the early ministry of Ethan Smith in Haverhill, New Hampshire.

1890

Charles Chase Lord reviews Ethan Smith's life sketch and biography.

1892 - 1928

Bibliography of Ethan Smith's publications.

1894

Rudolph Etzenhouser cites VOTH in defense of the BOM.

1895

Lloyd Vernon Briggs documents Ethan Smith's tenure as pastor of a church in Hanover, MA.

1896

Harriet Smith describes her father and provides a photograph of him.

Feb 1896

The Contributor cites View of the Hebrews as evidence for the Book of Mormon.

1897

Bibliography of some of Ethan Smith's published works.

Apr 1897

Self Culture answers questions related to the founding of the Church and VOTH.

1898

Isaac M. Smith (RLDS) defends the Book of Mormon by citing View of the Hebrews.

Jan 20, 1898

Millennial Star approvingly quotes Ethan Smith.

Dec 1898

Biographical sketch of Oliver Cowdery published in the Improvement Era.

1901

Andrew Jenson provides a biographical Sketch of Oliver Cowdery.

1902

Isaac Woodbridge Riley argues that JS was influenced by VOTH and other books.

Feb 19, 1902

S. W. L. Scott reports on debate where View of the Hebrews was claimed to be a source of plagiarism for the Book of Mormon.

Oct 1, 1902

George Reynolds republishes extracts of VOTH in the Church's periodical Juvenile Instructor.

1903

Church YMMIA manual (reprint of B. H. Roberts) cites VOTH.

Aug 19, 1903

Rudolph Etzenhouser reports on a debate on the Book of Mormon where View of the Hebrews was invoked as a potential source of plagiarism.

Aug 21, 1903

The Poultney Journal recounts briefly Ethan Smith's pastorate in the town.

1906

The Jewish Encyclopedia mentions the Book of Mormon in the context of "North-American Indians" and the Hebraic Indians theory.

1907

Thomas William Herringshaw gives biographical sketches of both Ethan and Joseph Smith.

1908

Henry A. Stebbins cites Ethan Smith and other authors in favor of the BOM.

1909

B. H. Roberts argues the JS could not have derived the BOM from VOTH.

Aug 26, 1909

Clark Braden argues Parley Pratt's Voice of Warning plagiarized View of the Hebrews.

1910

Charles A. Shook contextualizes the BOM alongside other works of the "Hebraic Indian" theory.

1910

Brief sketch of Ethan Smith's pastorate in Hanover, New Hampshire.

1911

Family History of Benjamin Franklin Cowdery, a cousin of Oliver Cowdery; mentions that Benjamin was a printer.

1911

Genealogical note on Rebecca Marie Cowdery being born in Williamson, New York.

1912

Eduard Meyer argues for environmental influences on the Book of Mormon, including potentially View of the Hebrews.

1914

Charles A. Shook suggests Ethan Smith is a source of inspiration for the Book of Mormon.

1915

John M. Comstock lists the first few pastors of the Congregational Church in Poultney.

1916

Edmund C. Briggs recalls Emma Hale Smith saying JS was ignorant of Jerusalem having walls.

Sep 13, 1918

The Poultney Journal publishes a brief history of the printing venture of Ethan Smith and his son.

1920

Clark Braden cites VOTH as a source of early Mormon plagiarism.

Dec 14, 1923

The Poultney Journal recounts the history of Smith & Shute's publishing venture.

Oct 1927

B. H. Roberts original manuscript of "A Parallel" listing 18 points of parallel between View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon.

Oct 24, 1927

B. H. Roberts writes letter to Richard R. Lyman explaining the intent of his "A Parallel" manuscript.

1930 - 1950

Dale Morgan posits that VOTH and the BOM emerged in the same cultural context.

Jun 26, 1930

Springfield Republican mentions View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon together in an article on the origins of Native Americans.

1932

George Bartholomew Arbaugh compares the ideas in the Book of Mormon with View of the Hebrews and other contemporary works.

1933 - 1967

Antoine R. Ivins's copy of B. H. Robert's "A Parallel".

1934

Lee M. Friedman briefly discusses View of the Hebrews in a book on the history of Jews in America.

Mar 16, 1935

Francis W. Kirkham reviews the argument that Joseph was influenced by View of the Hebrews and other works.

1936

Milton Wheaton Hamilton provides biographical sketch of Benjamin Franklin Cowdery, Oliver Cowdery's printer relative.

1937

Josiah E. Hickman cites Ethan Smith as evidence for the Book of Mormon.

Jul 22, 1939

Ben E. Roberts writes letter explaining his father's studies of the Book of Mormon and View of the Hebrews.

Jul 19, 1941

E. Cecil McGavin mentions VOTH in an apologetic piece for the Deseret News.

Aug 9, 1941

E. Cecil McGavin mentions VOTH and contrasts it with the BOM.

1944

Daryl Chase contrasts View of the Hebrews with the Book of Mormon in terms of the intent of each book.

1945

Fawn Brodie argues that VOTH was a source of inspiration for Joseph Smith.

May 11, 1946

Deseret News author rejects Fawn Brodie's argument that the Book of Mormon is dependent on View of the Hebrews.

May 1948

Liahona (Mexico) cites View of the Hebrews as evidence for the Book of Mormon.

Jun 1949

Edward Hoagland Brown suggests Ethan Smith and VOTH "inspired" JS.

1951

Francis W. Kirkham argues against Book of Mormon dependence on View of the Hebrews.

1953

Franklin S. Harris, Jr. responds to arguments that the Book of Mormon is reliant on View of the Hebrews.

1954

G. T. Harrison writes speculative fictional account of Joseph Smith meeting Ethan Smith.

Mar 1954

Hugh W. Nibley disputes the resemblance claimed between View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon.

Jan 1956

Mervin B. Hogan publishes B. H. Roberts' "A Parallel" study comparing View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon; describes the meeting where the manuscript was distributed.

1957

Thomas F. O'Dea reviews View of the Hebrews, concludes Joseph may have read it.

Oct 1959

Hugh W. Nibley reviews Fawn Brodie's arguments for the Book of Mormon's dependency on View of the Hebrews.

Nov 1959

Hugh W. Nibley reviews the argument that the Book of Mormon is dependent on View of the Hebrews.

Dec 1959

Marvin S. Hill reviews Brodie's argument that the Book of Mormon derived from View of the Hebrews.

1960

Leslie Rumble argues that Joseph directly took inspiration from View of the Hebrews.

1961

Ariel L. Crowley reviews View Of The Hebrews and the Book of Mormon together; argues against dependence or borrowing.

1961

Joseph Fielding Smith says the Church has a copy of View Of The Hebrews in its archives.

1961

G. T. Harrison lists parallels between VOTH and the BOM and argues for dependence.

1962

Stanley R. Gunn describes Oliver meeting the Smith family in 1828-1829; notes a family connection.

1962

Samuel Sandmel defines "parallelomania."

Aug 1, 1962

Charles A. Davies defends the BOM from claims of plagiarizing VOTH.

1963

Hal Hougey argues that Joseph plagiarized View of the Hebrews; gives list of parallels between View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon.

1964

Sidney B. Sperry disputes the claim of the Book of Mormon's dependence on View of the Hebrews.

1964

Spencer J. Palmer and William L. Knecht dispute the dependance of the Book of Mormon's Isaiah chapters on View of the Hebrews.

1964

Unpublished study by Paul R. Cheesman comparing View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon; rejects claims that the latter is dependent on the former.

1964

Wesley M. Jones argues for the BOM's dependence on VOTH.

1964

William J. Whalen summarizes the arguments for the Book of Mormon's dependence on View of the Hebrews; says the evidence is inconclusive.

Aug 21, 1964

Time Magazine explores the parallels between Abraham Lincoln and John F. Kennedy.

1965

Modern Microfilm Company reprint of VOTH with critical introductory comments.

1966

Wesley M. Jones argues that Joseph was directly influenced by Ethan Smith.

1969

Åke V. Ström posits that Joseph might have been influenced by Solomon Spaulding and/or Ethan Smith.

1970

Wayne Ham mentions View of the Hebrews as a cultural influence on the Book of Mormon.

1970

Robert N. Hullinger argues that Joseph Smith wrote the Book of Mormon to validate the theories of Ethan Smith.

1970

Genealogical material on the Cowdery family prepared by Carl C. Curtis.

1971

William L. Riley compares Isaiah quotations in View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon; finds no meaningful connection or evidence for dependence.

1972

Maurice C. Burrell follows Brodie in suggesting the BOM's dependence on VOTH.

Sep 1972

Roy E. Weldon (RLDS) reacts to claims that the Book of Mormon is dependent on View of the Hebrews.

1974

John A. Price says JS drew heavily from VOTH.

1975

Melaine N. Layton argues for parallels between View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon.

Apr 22, 1976

Emily A. Ross discusses Oliver Cowdery's possible connection with Ethan Smith.

Sep 1976

Bruce D. Blumell responds to claims that the Book of Mormon derives from View of the Hebrews in the Ensign.

1977

Gordon H. Fraser posits that Oliver Cowdery is the link between the Book of Mormon and View of the Hebrews.

1977

Donna Hill mentions arguments that Joseph was influenced by View of the Hebrews.

1978

James D. Wardle enumerates points of parallel between VOTH and the Book of Mormon.

1979

Truman G. Madsen summarizes B. H. Roberts's studies of View of the Hebrews during the 1920s.

1979

Wesley P. Walters in Journal of Pastoral Practice argues that Oliver Cowdery could have supplied VOTH to JS.

Dec 3, 1979

Thomas Stuart Ferguson voices his belief that JS had access to and used VOTH.

1980

Robert N. Hullinger says JS drew inspiration from Ethan Smith's work for apologetic purposes.

1980

Robert N. Hullinger argues it is a "strong case" that JS directly borrowed from VOTH.

1980

Gustav H. Blanke reviews the BOM in the context of Hebraic Indian theories of the 19th century.

1981

Michael T. Griffith responds to arguments for the BOM's dependence on VOTH in an unpublished manuscript.

1981

George D. Smith summarizes the argument for the Book of Mormon's dependence on View of the Hebrews.

1981

Michael T. Griffith argues against claims of the BOM's dependence on VOTH.

1981

Klaus J. Hansen summarizes View of the Hebrews theory for the Book of Mormon; says its difficult to prove.

May 1981 - Jun 1981

Madison U. Sowell reviews the View of the Hebrews controversy, concludes the debate is indecisive.

1982

C. Wilfred Griggs dismisses parallels between View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon as "superficial."

1982

Truman G. Madsen reviews B. H. Roberts' studies on the Book of Mormon and View of the Hebrews.

1982

Erich Robert Paul summarizes the holdings of the Manchester Library; notes the absence of VOTH but the presence of works that quote VOTH.

1983 - 1984

George D. Smith argues the parallels between View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon are "persuasive" to show dependency.

Jan 10, 1983

Thomas Stuart Ferguson postulates a connection between Oliver Cowdery and Ethan Smith.

Dec 1983

Truman G. Madsen reviews B. H. Roberts's study of VOTH in the Ensign.

1984

Ernest H. Taves argues for the Book of Mormon's dependence on View of the Hebrews.

1984

Richard Lyman Bushman reviews the controversy surrounding View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon; concludes direct influence between the two is unlikely.

1985

F. Edward Butterworth and Roy E. Weldon respond to claims that the Book of Mormon is dependent on View of the Hebrews.

1985

John W. Welch lists a variety of "unparallels" between View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon to argue against plagiarism or dependence.

1985

David Persuitte argues that Joseph had access to and drew directly from View of the Hebrews.

1985

William N. Goetzmann writes that JS may have heard about Hebraic Indian theories second or thirdhand from his environment.

Dec 15, 1985

John W. Welch reviews B. H. Roberts's BOM studies and the VOTH controversy.

1986

Gilbert W. Scharffs responds to claims that the Book of Mormon derives from View of the Hebrews.

1986

Brant A. Gardner deconstructs Christianized images of Quetzalcoatl; argues the parallels with Christ are illusory.

1986

Dan Vogel reviews View of the Hebrews and the context of its reception; briefly mentions debates about its relationship to the Book of Mormon.

1986

T. L. Brink reviews David Persuitte's book Joseph Smith and the Origins of the Book of Mormon.

Mar 1986

John W. Welch mentions Ethan Smith and View Of The Hebrews in a 1986 Ensign article about B. H. Roberts.

1987

Blake T. Ostler argues the parallels between View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon are not significant.

1987

Harry L. Ropp argues in favor of VOTH being a source for the BOM.

1987

Donald S. Tingle reviews different theories for the origins of the Book of Mormon, including the View of the Hebrews theory.

1988

John W. Welch reviews the history of B. H. Roberts's "Studies of the Book of Mormon" and concludes Roberts did not lose his testimony.

1988

Bruce D. Blumell argues that the VOTH theory cannot adequately account for the Book of Mormon.

1989

Phillip R. Legg describes family relationship between the Cowderys and Smiths; describes Oliver's early childhood; mentions connection to Ethan Smith.

1990

L. Ara Norwood critiques David Persuitte's thesis that the BOM derives from VOTH.

1990

Wesley P. Walters argues that Joseph depended on View of the Hebrews in his use of Old Testament passages in the Book of Mormon.

Dec 7, 1991

The Church News reports on the publication of the Encyclopedia of Mormonism.

1992

John W. Welch argues for significant dissimilarities between View Of The Hebrews and the Book of Mormon.

1992

Stephen D. Ricks reviews and critiques Wesley P. Walters' work on the BOM and VOTH.

1992

Entry for Oliver Cowdery in the Encyclopedia of Mormonism.

1992

Robert Richards reviews View of the Hebrews for the Encyclopedia of Mormonism.

1992

Preface to the Encyclopedia of Mormonism mentions the oversight of Church leaders on the project.

1993

Michael T. Griffith pushes back against claims of the Book of Mormon's dependence on View of the Hebrews.

1993

John B. Wright argues that JS read and took inspiration from View of the Herbews.

Oct 1993

Gordon B. Hinckley voices his rejection of both the Solomon Spaulding and View Of The Hebrews theories for the origins of the BOM.

Jan 1994

John W. Welch points to the absence of a library in Harmony, PA, during the time of the translation of the Book of Mormon.

1994

Neal A. Maxwell briefly mentions VOTH and responds to claim of BOM dependence.

1994

Joseph L. Daleiden argues that Joseph directly plagiarized View of the Hebrews.

1994

Richard S. Van Wagoner speculates that Oliver Cowdery provided JS with VOTH and may have helped print the book.

1994

John L. Brooke postulates a connection between Ethan Smith and Oliver Cowdery.

1995

Stephen R. Gibson responds to claims of Book of Mormon's dependence on View of the Hebrews.

1996

Stan Larson reviews the VOTH controversy and discusses Thomas Stuart Ferguson's loss of faith.

1996

Gershon Greenberg reviews Ethan Smith's eschatology in View of the Hebrews.

1996

1996 BYU edition of View of the Hebrews.

1997

Andrew H. Hedges positively reviews BYU's edition of View of the Hebrews and argues for little resemblance between it and the Book of Mormon.

1998

William D. Morain argues that View of the Hebrews influenced Joseph's thinking.

1998

Armand L. Mauss mentions View of the Hebrews as a hypothesized source for the Book of Mormon.

1998

Bruce Martin argues for why the Kennedy-Lincoln parallels are probably just coincidences.

1999

Robert D. Anderson suggests VOTH gave JS the "outline and concept" for the BOM and that Oliver Cowdery played a role in its conception.

2000

Charles D. Tate, Jr. summarizes VOTH in a Deseret Book publication.

2000

Larry E. Morris reviews the claim that Oliver Cowdery shared a relationship with Ethan Smith; concludes the evidence is not strong enough to establish such a claim; mentions that Oliver Cowdery was third cousins to Lucy Mack Smith.

2002

Diane E. Wirth argues for parallels between Jesus Christ and Quetzalcoatl.

2002

John Gee argues for dissimilarities between View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon.

2002

George D. Smith reviews B. H. Roberts's work on the Book of Mormon; concludes he probably became a skeptic; reviews the View of the Hebrews and Book of Mormon issue.

2002

Grant H. Palmer argues for the Book of Mormon's dependence on View of the Hebrews.

2002

Richard Abanes argues that Joseph directly plagiarized ideas from View of the Hebrews.

2002

Terryl Givens reviews the View of the Hebrews issue as it relates to the Book of Mormon.

2003

Richard Neitzel Holzapfel summarizes critical arguments against the Book of Mormon; mentions View of the Hebrews as one such argument.

2003

Charles D. Tate, Jr. summarizes VOTH for Deseret Book publication.

2003

David Pressley Bowman argues against the claim that the BOM is derived from VOTH.

2003

Arza Evans argues that the Book of Mormon "plagiarized" View of the Hebrews.

2004

Dan Vogel compares Joseph and the Book of Mormon with Ethan Smith's View of the Hebrews.

2004

Susan Stansfield Wolverton says Joseph probably was directly influenced by View of the Hebrews.

2004

Matthew O. Richardson describes Oliver Cowdery's relationship to the Smith family; notes he his third cousins once removed with JS.

2004

Richard Lyman Bushman voices concerns with comparing the Book of Mormon with View of the Hebrews.

2005

Matthew Roper critiques claims that Oliver Cowdery was in a conspiracy with Joseph Smith.

2005

Hartt Wixom critiques claims that the BOM is based on VOTH.

2005

H. Michael Marquardt situates the BOM in the context of the Hebraic Indian theory.

2005

Richard Lyman Bushman reviews View of the Hebrews and compares it with the Book of Mormon.

2005

Traci Thomas compares the narrative styles of View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon.

2006

Richard K. Behrens postulates a possible Hyrum Smith/VOTH connection.

2007

Brant A. Gardner argues that View of the Hebrews says more about how people read the Book of Mormon rather than how the book originated.

2007

Christopher Hitchens argues that the Book of Mormon's Isaiah chapters are derived from View of the Hebrews.

2007

Larry E. Morris reviews Oliver Cowdery's early life and conversion to the Church.

2009

Zvi Ben-Dor Benite discusses the Book of Mormon in the context of the Hebraic Indian Theory.

2009

Terryl Givens reviews the Solomon Spaulding and View of the Hebrews theories.

Oct 2009

Jeffrey R. Holland mentions Ethan Smith in a General Conference talk.

2012

Samuel Morris Brown briefly reviews VOTH.

2012

Paul C. Gutjahr briefly summarizes Oliver Cowdery meeting Joseph; suggests Oliver may have wanted to meet Joseph because of View of the Hebrews.

2013

Michael R. Ash responds to criticism that Joseph Smith plagiarized from View Of The Hebrews.

2013

Jeremy Runnells lists parallels between VOTH and the Book of Mormon.

2013

Eran Shalev contextualizes the Book of Mormon as part of the "Hebraic Indian" theory of the early 19th century.

2015

Michael R. Ash responds to the CES Letter's claims that the BOM derives from VOTH.

2015

Michael Hubbard Mackay and Gerrit Dirkmaat discuss Hebraic Indian theories in connection with the coming forth of the Book of Mormon.

Nov 1, 2016

Tad R. Callister discusses Solomon Spaulding and View Of The Hebrews in a BYU speech.

Oct 3, 2017

Royal Museums Greenwich website describes the parallels between the novel Futility and the sinking of the Titanic.

2018

Jim Bennett responds to the CES Letter's claims about View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon.

2019

Robert M. Bowman Jr. summarizes claims about View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon.

2019

Elizabeth Fenton argues the Book of Mormon is in some ways dissimilar from contemporary texts such as View of the Hebrews.

2019

Jeremy Talmage notes that the BOM and VOTH diverge on how they describe the skin color of Native Americans.

2020

The Church's website addresses arguments that the Book of Mormon derives from Solomon Spaulding and View of the Hebrews.

2020

Elizabeth Fenton reviews the View of the Hebrews controversy as it relates to the Book of Mormon.

Jan 23, 2020

Tad R. Callister responds to the claim that the Book of Mormon is derived from View of the Hebrews.

2021

Matthew W. Dougherty discusses the Book of Mormon's relationship with Ethan Smith and other authors.

2022

Gregory Dundas reviews the theory that View of the Hebrews is a source for the Book of Mormon.

2022

Andrew Tobolowsky discusses View of the Hebrews and its historical context in relation to the Book of Mormon.

2022

Ronald Helfrich, Jr. says parallels between the Book of Mormon and View of the Hebrews could be because of a shared cultural environment, not by direct borrowing.

2023

Grant Hardy summarizes various theories for Book of Mormon authorship, including the View of the Hebrews theory.

2024

Church History essays reviews the Smith family living in Palmyra/Manchester.

2024

Jeff Lindsay's satirical post comparing the "parallels" between the BOM and Leaves of Grass.

2024

Biographical entry for William Cowdery on the Joseph Smith Papers website.

2024

JSP website gives overview of Manchester Township, where the Smith family lived.

2024

The Joseph Smith Papers Website gives overview of Palmyra Township, where the Smith family lived.

2024

Surah 39:72 of the Quran says the arrogant/proud will suffer in hell.

2024

Church History Library shows holdings from View of the Hebrews.

2024

2 Esdras 13:40–41 describes ancient Israelite migrations.

2024

BYU library catalogues lists copies of View of the Hebrews in its holdings.