Book of Mormon Origins

326 Primary Sources

Date
Summary
1737 - 1835

Town of Rowley records show John Smith as son of Joseph Smith and Sarah Sawyer.

1748

French maps of Anjouan, an island of Comoros, includes city of Meroni.

1751 - 1800

The Comoros Islands on maps of Africa from 1751 to 1800.

Dec 15, 1751

Byfield Parish Church record of the christening of John Smith, son of Joseph Smith, in 1751.

May 31, 1790

U.S. Congress 1790 Copyright Act.

1801 - 1825

The Comoros Islands on maps of Africa from 1801 to 1825.

1806 - 1908

Birth record for Oliver Cowdery gives October 3, 1806 as his birth date.

1809

The preface and contents of The First Book of Napoleon.

May 26, 1811

Poultney Church record indicates Keziah Cowdery, Oliver Cowdery's stepmother, joined the congregation in May 1811.

Aug 30, 1813 - Jun 4, 1814

Joseph Perry records the students of Moor's Indian Charity School for the year of 1813-1814, and Hyrum Smith is not listed.

Aug 28, 1814 - Aug 23, 1815

Joseph Perry records the students of Moor's Indian Charity School for the year of 1814-1815, with Hyrum Smith present for the first quarter.

1816

Gilbert Hunt says that he wrote The Late War in "imitation of the oriental" style.

Jul 9, 1816

The Commonwealth reports that Sidney Rigdon and Solomon Spaulding have letters at the Pittsburgh post office.

Aug 22, 1816

Joseph Perry records the students present for examinations in the end of 1816, and Hyrum Smith is not listed.

Aug 2, 1818

Poultney Church records indicate Oliver Cowdery's half-sisters were baptized into the church.

1819

Samuel Mitchell writes that The Late War is written in "the biblical style."

Dec 17, 1823

Poultney Gazette publishes outline of VOTH.

Dec 23, 1823

Saratoga Sentinel publishes negative review of VOTH.

Dec 27, 1823

Boston Recorder reviews VOTH.

Feb 12, 1824

Vermont Gazette advertises VOTH for sale.

Apr 10, 1824

The American Monthly Magazine uses the phrase "narrow neck of land" in 1824, reprinted in The Pennsylvanian.

Jun 1, 1824

The Long-Island Star retells a story about Captain Kidd hiding treasure in a hill in upstate New York.

1825

Josiah Priest uses the phrase "narrow neck of land" in his book Wonders of Nature and Providence, Displayed.

1825

Ethan Smith summarizes his arguments for the Indians being descendants of the Lost Tribes.

1825

Introduction to the 2nd edition of VOTH.

1825

Ethan Smith summarizes his case for Native Americans being the Lost Tribes.

Feb 4, 1825

Jabez B. Hyde positively recommends the theory in VOTH.

Feb 16, 1825

The Wayne Sentinel reports on treasure diggers looking for treasure hidden by demons or Captain Kidd.

May 1825

Review of VOTH in the Utica Christian Repository.

Jul 15, 1825

Daily National Intelligencer uses the phrase "narrow neck of land" in 1825.

May 14, 1827

Massachusetts Journal uses the phrase "narrow neck of land" in 1827, reprinted in Daily National Journal.

Jun 13, 1827

New-York Times article on Captain “Robert” Kidd mentions popularity of his stories and buried treasure, reprinted in The Farmers’ Journal.

1828

Webster’s 1828 dictionary definition of "illiterate."

1828

Matthew Henry’s Bible commentary on Galatians 1:8.

1828

An 1828 essay discusses the Batman Su river.

Apr 1828 - May 1828

Joseph Smith says he started translating the Book of Mormon with Martin Harris as his scribe on April 12, 1828.

1829

Barbara Anne Simon cites VOTH in arguing for the Hebraic Indian theory.

Apr 1829

Joseph Smith receives revelation for Oliver Cowdery that translation is done according to faith.

Apr 1829

Revelation to Oliver Cowdery on how he cannot translate the Book of Mormon.

Apr 1829 - Jun 1829

Original Manuscript of the Book of Mormon shows "second" was inserted at the beginning of "the Book of <second> Nephi."

Apr 12, 1829 - Jul 31, 1829

Joseph Smith's handwriting in original Book of Mormon manuscript.

Jun 26, 1829

Wayne Sentinel reports on the "pretended discovery" and translation of the "Golden Bible," says most people don't believe in it.

Aug 1829 - Jan 1830

First pages of First and Second Nephi in the Printer's Manuscript of the Book of Mormon have "first" and "second" inserted above the lines.

Aug 11, 1829

Palmyra Freeman reports on story of an angel appearing to Joseph Smith, the Book of Mormon translation, and refers to Joseph as "very illiterate."

Aug 31, 1829

Rochester Daily Advertiser reprints "Golden Bible" article from the Palmyra Freeman.

Sep 25, 1829

Brattleboro' Messenger reprints "Golden Bible" article from Palmyra Freeman.

Oct 7, 1829

The Farmers' Journal (Canada) reprints "Golden Bible" article from the Palmyra Freeman.

Oct 17, 1829

Norwalk Reporter reprints "Golden Bible" article from the Palmyra Freeman.

1830

Joseph says he translated the Book of Mormon “by the gift and power of God” in its preface.

1830

Copyright page of the 1830 edition of the Book of Mormon.

1830

The 1830 titlepage of the Book of Mormon.

Feb 20, 1830

C. C. Blatchley criticizes Book of Mormon text, says Joseph Smith is the author in New-York Telescope article.

Mar 26, 1830

The Wayne Sentinel announces that the Book of Mormon is for sale.

Jun 12, 1830

Abner Cole, parodying the Book of Mormon, writes that Joseph Smith was influenced by Walters the Magician.

Aug 1830

Earliest version of an 1830 revelation (D&C 27) on wine in the sacrament.

Nov 25, 1830

Cleveland Herald says Joseph Smith and Oliver Cowdery altered the "old Bible" to make the Book of Mormon.

Jan 15, 1831

W. W. Phelps says that Joseph and the Smith family lack education, published in Mormonism Unvailed.

Feb 1, 1831

Palmyra Reflector describes Joseph and the Smith family as uneducated and ignorant.

Feb 10, 1831

Alexander Campbell says Joseph Smith is the author of the Book of Mormon.

Feb 15, 1831

The Cleveland Advertiser claims Sidney Rigdon wrote the Book of Mormon.

Feb 28, 1831

Abner Cole claims Joseph Smith was influenced to create the Book of Mormon by Luman Walters, details their money-digging and magic practices.

Aug 31, 1831

Morning Courier and New-York Enquirer say an acclaimed money-digger named "Henry Ringdon" helped the Smith's dig for treasure between Manchester and Palmyra.

Sep 1, 1831

Morning Courier and New-York Enquirer says Joseph Smith and Sidney Rigdon came up with the Book of Mormon to make money.

Nov 3, 1831

Revelation to Joseph Smith connects the restoration to Revelation 14:6.

1832

Alexander Campbell concludes that Joseph Smith wrote the Book of Mormon himself.

1832

Joseph Smith says he translated 116 pages of manuscript that Martin Harris lost.

1832

Joseph Smith's 1832 history describing Moroni’s visit.

1832

Alexander Campbell implies the Book of Mormon came from Satan.

Jun 1, 1832

Joseph Smith says he had some education in reading, writing, and arithmetic.

1833

Josiah Priest quotes VOTH in his American Antiquities.

Dec 20, 1833

The Wayne Sentinel reports that Doctor Philastus Hurlbut has found evidence that the Book of Mormon came from a thirty year old manuscript.

1834

Isaac Hale says Martin Harris acted as Joseph Smith's scribe, and then Oliver Cowdery.

1834

E. D. Howe claims Joseph Smith was searching for Captain Kidd’s money when he claimed to have found the plates.

1834

J. Orville Taylor provides commentary on public schools and teachers during Joseph's time.

1834

In Mormonism Unvailed, E. D. Howe suggests that the Book of Mormon is plagiarized from Solomon Spaulding's manuscript.

Jan 31, 1834

A committee in Kirtland, Ohio announces that they gathered information tying Solomon Spaulding to the Book of Mormon.

Oct 1, 1834

Oliver Cowdery says he first met Joseph Smith on April 5, 1829; describes Book of Mormon translation process.

1835

Josiah Priest says the Book of Mormon is a poor imitation of the Old Testament.

1835

Revised version of an 1830 revelation (D&C 27) as printed in the 1835 Doctrine and Covenants.

Nov 9, 1835

Joseph said that he translated the Book of Mormon by the gift and power of God and could not translate when he was in transgression.

Mar 31, 1836

John Whitmer testifies of having handled the plates.

1837

Title page of the 1837 edition of the Book of Mormon.

Jan 7, 1837

Clericus reports on Mormonism Unvailed and the Spaulding manuscript.

1838 - 1839

Joseph describes translation "drawing to a close" as they obtain a copyright for the Book of Mormon.

1838

Samuel Williams claims that Sidney Rigdon used Solomon Spaulding's manuscript to write the Book of Mormon.

1838

Parley P. Pratt explains how he introduced Sidney Rigdon to the Book of Mormon.

1839

Samuel and Hyrum Smith’s visits to Joseph during the Book of Mormon translation.

1839

Joseph Smith’s history says Oliver Cowdery began work as his scribe on April 7, 1829.

Apr 19, 1839

John Storrs includes affidavit from Matilda Spaulding Davison and writes in support of the Spaulding theory in letter to the Boston Recorder editor.

Apr 27, 1839

Boston Daily Advertiser says the Spaulding theory answers the question of the Book of Mormon's origins, reprints Boston Recorder affidavit from Matilda Spaulding Davison.

May 7, 1839

Gazette and Mercury says the Spaulding theory answers the question of the Book of Mormon's origins.

Jun 1839

Alexander Campbell writes that he believes the Spaulding theory.

Jun 8, 1839

Sidney Rigdon denies knowledge of the Spaulding manuscript.

Jun 26, 1839 - Aug 4, 1839

Willard Richards records Joseph Smith's teachings on detecting angels.

Jun 27, 1839

Wilford Woodruff records Joseph Smith's teachings on detecting Angels.

Dec 24, 1840

The Madisonian publishes detailed review of the Book of Mormon.

Dec 31, 1840

Orson Pratt records that schooling was available to Joseph.

1841

William Harris says that Joseph Smith could not have produced the Book of Mormon on his own.

Feb 15, 1841

The Anti-Mormon Almanac says that the Devil wrote the Book of Mormon.

Mar 21, 1841

Martha Jane Knowlton Coray notes Joseph’s teachings on detecting true angels.

1842

J. B. Turner says Joseph Smith is the sole author of the Book of Mormon.

Mar 1, 1842

Joseph Smith says the angel that appeared in 1823 gave him "a brief sketch" of ancient American civilization.

Apr 1, 1842

Times and Seasons article, likely written by Joseph Smith, teaches about the discerning of spirits.

Jun 1, 1842

Joseph Smith, as editor of Times and Seasons, publishes an extract from American Antiquities that quotes View Of The Hebrews.

Jul 28, 1842

Jonathan Hadley writes that Joseph is "too stupid" to have written the Book of Mormon and believes in Spaulding theory, as printed in the Lowell Courier.

Sep 7, 1842

Joseph records an appearance of the archangel Michael on the banks of the Susquehanna river "detecting the devil" who appeared as an angel of light.

Oct 18, 1842

Susan Smith recalls Reverend John Smith's mother was a Sawyer.

Feb 9, 1843

William Clayton records Joseph Smith’s teachings on detecting false angels.

Mar 5, 1843

Charlotte Haven says Sidney Rigdon is much smarter than Joseph Smith and was likely the author of the Book of Mormon.

May 1, 1843

Times and Seasons includes a biography of Sidney Rigdon's early life in the "History of Joseph Smith," part 1.

May 15, 1843

Times and Seasons includes a biography of Sidney Rigdon's life in the "History of Joseph Smith," part 2.

Jul 26, 1843

Tyler Parsons quotes statements from Mormonism Unvailed about the Spaulding manuscript.

1844 - 1845

Lucy Mack Smith reports that Joseph Smith was not interested in reading as a youth.

1844 - 1845

Lucy Mack Smith recounts Joseph seeing the angel, receiving instruction, and telling the family about ancient Americans.

1844 - 1845

Lucy Mack Smith tells of the Smith family's early debts, limited education, farming, and Joseph Sr. teaching school.

1845

U.S. Congress 1802 Copyright Act.

1845

Lucy Mack Smith describes Hyrum Smith's education.

May 30, 1847

Hiram Page reaffirms his testimony of the Book of Mormon.

Oct 21, 1848

Oliver Cowdery testifies of the plates, Book of Mormon translation, priesthood restoration by angels.

Oct 21, 1848

Reuben Miller records Oliver Cowdery stating how Joseph translated the BOM and Rigdon did not make it up.

1852

Orsamus Turner’s book chapter says the Book of Mormon came from Lucy Mack Smith, Joseph Smith Sr. and Oliver Cowdery.

Apr 23, 1859

Millennial Star republishes an extract from View of the Hebrews.

Aug 14, 1859

Orson Pratt describes Joseph Smith's limited education.

Aug 20, 1859

Martin Harris affirms his testimony of Joseph Smith and the Book of Mormon.

Aug 20, 1859

Millennial Star reprints Oliver Cowdery testimony of the Book of Mormon, the plates and translation, the appearance of angels.

1863

The New American Cyclopaedia reports details of the Spaulding theory.

1867

Pomeroy Tucker claims Joseph Smith often read stories of Captain Kidd, and later frequently read the Bible.

1867

George Thomas Chapman's entry for Dr. John Smith in the Sketches of the Alumni at Dartmouth that erroneously identifies his father as the Joseph Smith married to Elisabeth Palmer.

Apr 8, 1867

George Thomas Chapman explains the limitations of the Sketches of Dartmouth alumni, and that some inaccuracies are to be expected.

Apr 8, 1867

Biographical sketch of Solomon Spaulding.

1867

Pomeroy Tucker says Joseph and the Smith family were illiterate and irrelgious.

Dec 31, 1867

Pomeroy Tucker reports that Joseph knew a lot of stories about Captain Kidd.

1869

Hiland Paul and Robert Parks describe the Cowdery family history in Rutland County.

Mar 11, 1869

J. G. Hale recounts history of Ethan Smith's pastorate in Poultney; discusses the details of his dismissal from the church.

1873

T. B. H. Stenhouse claims Joseph Smith may have used spiritualism to write the Book of Mormon, doesn't believe Spaulding theory.

Aug 2, 1878

Myron H. Bond recollects that John Whitmer was a scribe during translation and "saw and handled" the plates.

Aug 31, 1878

William Sayre mentions a man who claimed in 1829 that Joseph Smith Sr. created the Book of Mormon.

Jun 15, 1879

W. W. Blair recounts interview with Michael Morse; Morse recounts the Book of Mormon dictation, says Joseph was unlearned and incapable of composing it himself.

Oct 1, 1879

Emma Smith says Joseph Smith did not use manuscripts or notes while dictating the Book of Mormon.

Oct 1, 1879

Emma Hale Smith on Joseph Smith being poor at dictation and writing.

1880

W. Lang provides brief biographical sketch of Oliver Cowdery.

Dec 29, 1880

Simon Smith recalls hearing Martin Harris bear testimony of the Book of Mormon on his deathbed.

1881

Anna Ruth Webster Eaton claims Captain Kidd was Joseph Smith's "hero," that Lucy Mack Smith influenced Joseph to be a prophet, and the Book of Mormon came from Solomon Spaulding.

Jun 5, 1881

David Whitmer describes Book of Mormon translation process.

Nov 30, 1881

Edward Stevenson retells how Martin Harris unsuccessfully tried to trick Joseph during the translation by replacing seer stone with an ordinary stone, printed in the Deseret News.

1884

Clark Braden supports the Spaulding-Rigdon theory, says Church members took arguments for the Book of Mormon from Josiah Priest's book Wonders of Nature and Providence Displayed.

1885

RLDS Church publishes two letters from L. L. Rice to Joseph Smith III about Solomon Spaulding's Manuscript Found, along with the entire manuscript.

1885

Ellen E. Dickinson interviews Doctor Philastus Hurlbut about the Spaulding manuscript.

1885

James H. Fairchild found no resemblance between the Spaulding manuscript and the Book of Mormon.

Jun 6, 1885

The Santa Maria times reports the finding of the Spaulding manuscript and the circulation of the claims of a second manuscript.

Dec 17, 1885

David Whitmer recounts Joseph using Urim and Thummim to translate the Book of Mormon.

1886

Preface to the Deseret News edition of "Manuscript Found."

Jun 21, 1886

Martin Harris says Joseph used the seer stone in a hat to translate the BOM.

Mar 7, 1887

Lucy Cowdery Young, Oliver's half-sister, gives short biography of Oliver Cowdery; mentions he left for NY in circa 1825 and met the Smiths circa 1829.

Apr 24, 1887

The Cleveland Plain Dealer alleges that Joseph Smith wrote the Book of Mormon using Solomon Spaulding's Manuscript Found which was based on an unpublished book by Ethan Smith.

1887

David Whitmer said that the Book of Mormon was not translated by the power of man.

1888

Parley P. Pratt recounts learning about the Book of Mormon and testifies of its authenticity.

1888

James Harrison Kennedy repeats claims that Joseph Smith Jr. read Captain Kidd stories and that Joseph Sr. searched for Kidd's treasure.

1888

W. R. Hine says that Joseph Smith had a vision of Captain Kidd.

1890

Thomas Gregg's late retelling of Joseph Smith's life and interest in Captain Kidd's treasure, including a letter from Stephen S. Harding.

Feb 1896

The Contributor cites View of the Hebrews as evidence for the Book of Mormon.

1897

D. H. Bays recounts the Spaulding manuscript theory and calls it a "failure."

1899

Lily Dougall writes that Joseph Smith was "genuinely deluded" in his religious thinking and likely wrote the Book of Mormon himself.

1901

Andrew Jenson provides a biographical sketch of Oliver Cowdery.

1902

Isaac Woodbridge Riley claims Joseph Smith had epilepsy and produced the Book of Mormon through automatic writing.

Feb 19, 1902

S. W. L. Scott reports on debate where Elder Bridwell claims View of the Hebrews was a source of plagiarism for the Book of Mormon.

May 1902

Isaac Woodbridge Riley says Joseph Smith was influenced by View of the Hebrews and other books.

Mar 28, 1908

The Deseret Evening News reports that Sidney Rigdon testified of the Book of Mormon later in life, according to his son.

1909

B. H. Roberts argues the Joseph Smith could not have derived the Book of Mormon from View of the Hebrews.

1916

Edmund C. Briggs recalls Emma Hale Smith saying Joseph Smith was ignorant of Jerusalem having walls.

Jul 1917

Walter Franklin Prince argues that Joseph Smith wrote the Book of Mormon himself with an unconscious masonic influence.

Jan 1930

Bernard DeVoto says Joseph Smith was a "paranoid" that experienced hallucinations, says Book of Mormon was influenced by Solomon Spaulding's Manuscript Found and Sidney Rigdon.

1931

Harry M. Beardsley claims Joseph Smith had dementia præcox (schizophrenia), which helped him produce the Book of Mormon.

1937

M. D. Bown lists 100 similarities he saw between the Spaulding manuscript and the Book of Mormon.

1937

M. D. Bown explains the different kinds of similarities he found between the Spaulding manuscript and the Book of Mormon.

1939

Willard S. Elsbree describes teachers and schools in the early 19th century.

1945

Fawn Brodie asserts that Joseph Smith made up the Book of Mormon.

1945

Fawn Brodie argues that View of the Hebrews was a source of inspiration for Joseph Smith.

1951

Francis W. Kirkham argues against Book of Mormon dependence on View of the Hebrews.

Oct 1959

Hugh Nibley criticizes parallels found between the Spaulding manuscript and the Book of Mormon.

Nov 1959

Hugh W. Nibley reviews the argument that the Book of Mormon is dependent on View of the Hebrews.

1961

Ariel L. Crowley reviews View Of The Hebrews and the Book of Mormon together; argues against dependence or borrowing.

1964

Sidney B. Sperry disputes the claim of the Book of Mormon's dependence on View of the Hebrews.

1967

Sidney B. Sperry critiques the Spaulding theory and theory of two manuscripts.

1976

Entry for "Moloka'i" in Place Names of Hawaii.

Apr 22, 1976

Emily A. Ross discusses Oliver Cowdery's possible connection with Ethan Smith.

1981

Klaus J. Hansen says epilepsy and automatic writing theories for Joseph Smith are unlikely, comments on "bicameral" and schizophrenia framework for Joseph Smith.

1981

Church Institute manual says 35% of Isaiah appears in the Book of Mormon.

1982

Erich Robert Paul notes the presence of Wonders of Nature in the Manchester Library and the lack of evidence that Joseph Smith was a patron there.

1983

Vernal Holley ties the Spaulding theory to New England geography for Book of Mormon place names.

1985

F. Edward Butterworth and Roy E. Weldon respond to claims that the Book of Mormon is dependent on View of the Hebrews.

1985

John W. Welch lists a variety of "unparallels" between View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon to argue against plagiarism or dependence.

1987

The Tanners argue that the Book of Mormon anachronistically borrows from the Bible and Apocrypha.

1987

The Tanners argue that the Book of Mormon reflects 19th-century Anti-Masonic rhetoric and sentiment.

1987

The Tanners argue that the Book of Mormon reflects 19th-century Anti-Universalist rhetoric.

1987

The Tanners argue that the Book of Mormon responds, in part, to the works of Thomas Paine and other deists in the Book of Mormon.

1987

The Tanners claim that the Book of Mormon takes from The Wonders of Nature and Shakespeare, implies connection to View of the Hebrews.

1987

The Tanners argue that the Book of Mormon interacts with 19th-century American religious circumstances, including revivals and Alexander Campbell's views on infant baptism.

1987

Blake T. Ostler argues the parallels between View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon are not significant.

1989

Dan Vogel argues that the Book of Mormon reflects 19th-century Anti-Masonic sentiment.

1992

Miriam Smith and John Welch explain Joseph Smith being the "Author and Proprietor" in the first edition of the Book of Mormon.

1992

Matthew Roper argues against Sandra and Jerald Tanner's suggestion that The Wonders of Nature and Providence influenced the Book of Mormon.

1993

Lawrence Foster writes that a manic-depressive illness may explain Joseph Smith's behavior.

1994

Robert D. Anderson writes that Joseph Smith did not have Bipolar Disorder, and that the condition would not have aided him in creating the Book of Mormon; says the Book of Mormon may help analyze Smith's mind.

1994

Information on Moroni, the capital of Comoros.

1994

Richard S. Van Wagoner writes about Sidney Rigdon's early years and preaching.

1995

Fawn Brodie concludes that the Spaulding-Rigdon theory is not supported by the historical evidence.

1996 - 1997

T. Sinclair says the Batman Su river was likely named after a nearby settlement.

1996

Stan Larson reviews the View of the Hebrews controversy and discusses Thomas Stuart Ferguson's loss of faith.

1996

Chapter 1 of Manuscript Found introduces the author as a Roman sent to Britain who was blown off course.

1996

The Romans in Spaulding's Manuscript Found choose a man to be a minister of Jesus Christ.

1996

Spaulding's Manuscript Found mentions a character riding a horse.

1997

Ed Decker and Dave Hunt claim in The God Makers that Joseph Smith was led by Satan.

1998

William D. Morain writes that Joseph Smith's leg surgery left him with a dissociative mental condition that influenced his creation of the Book of Mormon.

1998

D. Michael Quinn provides various proposals for the origin of "Moroni" from magical texts and other literature of Joseph's time.

1998

William D. Morain argues that View of the Hebrews, anti-masonry and other sources influenced Joseph Smith's creation of the Book of Mormon.

2000

Richard N. Williams critiques William D. Morain's book on Joseph Smith and dissociative disorder.

2000

Philetus Spear claims that Joseph Smith owned a copy of Captain Kidd stories.

2002

Scott C. Dunn compares Joseph Smith to Pearl Curran and automatic writing.

2002

Robert A. Rees argues that Joseph Smith did not have the knowledge to write the Book of Mormon himself.

2002

Robert A. Rees argues Joseph Smith did not have the literary skill to write the Book of Mormon himself.

2002

Grant Palmer says Joseph Smith's story about the origins of the Book of Mormon was influenced by Luman Walter's and The Golden Pot.

2002

Scott C. Dunn argues that Joseph Smith used automatic writing rather than divine aid to dictate the Book of Mormon.

2002

Robert A. Rees compares Joseph Smith's and other nineteenth century writers' literary careers and education.

2002

Grant H. Palmer argues for the Book of Mormon's dependence on View of the Hebrews.

May 20, 2002

Jeff Lindsay satirically argues that Joseph Smith plagiarized Walt Whitman's Leaves of Grass.

2003

Grant H. Palmer argues that 19th-century Evangelical Protestant theology is found throughout the Book of Mormon.

2003

Kurdish-English Dictionary entries for "batman."

2004

James B. Allen criticizes Grant H. Palmer's theory that Joseph Smith was influenced by E. T. A. Hoffmann's "The Golden Pot."

2004

Dan Vogel explains his view that Joseph Smith created the Book of Mormon himself.

2004

Dan Vogel compares Joseph Smith and the Book of Mormon with Ethan Smith's View of the Hebrews.

2005

Richard Bushman describes how the Book of Mormon might have been translated.

2005

Matthew Roper argues that there is not convincing evidence of two Spaulding manuscripts.

2006

Robert A. Rees concludes that Joseph Smith did not write the Book of Mormon by automatic writing.

2006

Richard K. Behrens proposes that Hyrum Smith taught Joseph Smith the theology that ended up in the Book of Mormon.

2006

Richard K. Behrens connects Joseph Smith Jr.'s paternal grandparents to the Joseph Smith and Elisabeth Palmer who were mistakenly identified as the parents of Reverend John Smith in a Dartmouth Alumni Sketch.

2006

Oxford Companion to Food describes mantou, which is called "manti" in parts of Central Asia.

2006

University of Washington Silk Road database entry on the Kingdom of Shule (Kashgar).

2006

Name of Bosnian city "Neum" associated with ancient site of Neuense.

Dec 31, 2006

Richard K. Behrens claims HS had access to Dartmouth educational ideas.

Jun 2007

Study by Santosa et al. reports connection between bipolar disorder and creativity.

2008

Rick Grunder argues that the Book of Mormon contains the same themes and language as The Late War.

2008

Rick Grunder argues that the Book of Mormon contains the same themes and language as The Late War.

Oct 2009

Elder Jeffrey R. Holland testifies the Book of Mormon is true and Joseph Smith did not lie about its origins.

Apr 10, 2010

Scott L. Harris says Joseph Smith only received demonic revelations.

2011

Kent P. Jackson writes on the Book of Mormon being revealed in the language of the King James Bible.

2013

Benjamin L. McGuire argues that Grunder confuses historical coincidence with meaningful influence in the origins of The Book of Mormon.

2013

Benjamin L. McGuire acknowledges that The Book of Mormon may share phrases with The Late War, but unlike the latter, it deeply engages with biblical themes and spiritual questions.

2013

Royal Skousen writes that First and Second Nephi were each originally just called "The Book of Nephi."

2013

The Revelation of John warns against changing the revelation itself.

2013

Paul warns the Galatians against accepting "another gospel."

2013

Noel A. Carmack says it’s possible Joseph Smith saw a map of Meroni and the Comoro Islands before 1830, discusses maps, Moroni, Moroon.

2013

Jeremy Runnells lists parallels between View of the Hebrews and the Book of Mormon.

Apr 2013

Jeremy Runnells repeats the claim that Joseph Smith plagiarized The Late War.

Apr 1, 2013

Condé Nast Traveler article on the naming of Batman, Türkiye.

Oct 25, 2013

Chris Johnson says the First Book of Napoleon contributed to the Book of Mormon, but The Late War is the most significant source.

Nov 6, 2013

G. Bruce Schaalje proposes a formula to determine the amount of influence of The Late War in The Book of Mormon.

Dec 2, 2013 - Feb 28, 2014

An exhibit summarized by DCL recounts the history of Moor's Charity school.

2014

Matt Roper et. al argue that The Book of Mormon's language shows distinct voices and is not stylistically similar to 19th century pseudo-biblical literature.

2014

Matt Roper et. al argue that The Book of Mormon's language shows distinct voices and is not stylistically similar to 19th century pseudo-biblical literature.

2014

Jeremy Runnells asserts that The Book of Mormon parallels The First Book of Napoleon.

2014

Jeremy Runnells claims that Joseph Smith took the name Cumorah from a map of Africa and Captain Kidd stories.

2014

The RDOCS gives biographical and academic details of Professor John Smith.

Mar 9, 2014

Chris and Duane Johnson claim that Joseph Smith was exposed to The Late War and that data analysis proves that its influence is evident in the Book of Mormon.

May 28, 2014

Osamu Muramoto writes on the retrospective diagnosis of historical figures.

Feb 9, 2016

Lost Mormonism repeats the supposition that the name Cumorah came from Captain Kidd legends.

Nov 1, 2016

Tad R. Callister discusses Solomon Spaulding and View Of The Hebrews in a BYU speech.

May 18, 2017

Wheat & Tares (blog) blogger Mary Ann notes that Holley's BoM place names theory is interesting but not convincing.

2018

John Welch describes replicating the Book of Mormon translation process.

2018

John Welch outlines the timeline for the translation of the Book of Mormon.

2018

Stanford Carmack critiques connections made between The Late War and the Book of Mormon.

2018

Stanford Carmack concludes the Book of Mormon uses early modern English and archaic grammar far beyond Joseph Smith’s abilities.

2018

Stanford Carmack concludes the Book of Mormon uses early modern English and archaic grammar far beyond Joseph Smith’s abilities.

2018

Arthur Chris Eccel gives a refutation of the Spalding-Rigdon theory.

Jan 2, 2018

Study by Kyaga et al. finds connection between creativity and schizophrenia, bipolar disorder.

2019

Brian C. Hales outlines views regarding Joseph Smith creating the Book of Mormon through mental illness.

2019

Brian C. Hales concludes that the creation of the Book of Mormon has similarities with automatic writing but that doesn't account for its origin.

2019

Scott Gordon argues that supposed similarities between the Book of Mormon and The First Book of Napoleon are misleadingly constructed from cherry-picked phrases taken out of context and out of order.

2019

Scott Gordon argues that supposed similarities between the Book of Mormon and The First Book of Napoleon are misleadingly constructed from cherry-picked phrases taken out of context and out of order.

2019

Village Chemish page on Guide-Bulgaria.com.

Jan 22, 2019

Lawrence E. Corbridge says disproving claims against the Church does not prove the Church is true.

Feb 13, 2019

Dan Vogel explains the Spaulding theory and why he does not believe it.

Jun 1, 2019

Robert Beckstead et al. speculate that Joseph Smith used psychoactive substances to write the Book of Mormon.

Jun 25, 2019

The blog Heavy Metal Mormon argues that there are no connections between The First Book of Napoleon and The Book of Mormon.

Jun 25, 2019

The blog Heavy Metal Mormon argues that there are no connections between The First Book of Napoleon and The Book of Mormon.

Jan 2020

Schmidt, Wilhelmy, and Gross write that retrospective diagnosis must be heavily scrutinized, and should only be done following rigorous methods.

Jan 1, 2020

Brian C. Hales rejects Robert Beckstead et al.'s findings about Joseph Smith's possible use of hallucinogenic drugs.

2020

Royal Skousen analyzes King James Bible passages in the Book of Mormon.

Oct 16, 2020

Paul Gee accuses Joseph Smith of following demons.

2023

Brian C. Hales summarizes Joseph Smith's writing projects before the Book of Mormon in 1829.

Feb 8, 2023

Randy Bell claims Joseph Smith received his theology from his brother Hyrum.

Oct 16, 2023

Jennifer Nicoloro-SantaBarbara et al. write about cognition in bipolar disorder.

Nov 4, 2023

Lisa Hoelzer repeats claims that Joseph Smith made up the Book of Mormon and lists common criticisms.

Dec 4, 2023

The Times of India reports on the Zoram People's Movement.

2024

Lars Nielsen’s explanation of the Book of Mormon draws on all major naturalistic claims.

2024

Wowpedia entry for Ogath the Mad.

2024

Lars Nielsen claims that Sidney Rigdon used Parley P. Pratt to collude with Joseph Smith to write the Book of Mormon.

2024

Gospel Topics essay on the Spaulding Manuscript.

Aug 2024

In the Liahona, Margot Hovley testifies of The Book of Mormon's divine origin.

Aug 26, 2024

Trent Horn references Galatians 1 and suggests the Book of Mormon could be a false gospel.

Aug 26, 2024

Trent Horn argues that demonic influence imitating divinity may be the source of the Book of Mormon.

2025

Cody Noconi bio on Mormons and Drugs Podcast website.

2025

Michael Winkelman bio on his website.

2025

Mormon Stories repeats claims that Joseph Smith made up the Book of Mormon.

2025

Britannica defines automatic writing as a spiritual practice.

2025

FAIR Latter-day Saints concludes that Vernal Holley's map tries to link Book of Mormon geography to 19th-century New England, but is based on flawed assumptions, circular reasoning, and doesn’t match the text.

2025

Academia profile for Robert T. Beckstead.

2025

Cody Noconi bio on Seer Stoned Productions website.

2025

Profile for Bryce Blankenagel on Glass Box Podcast website.

2025

FAIR argues that the Book of Mormon was not derived from The First Book of Napoleon, shows where CES Letter pulled phrases from.

2025

FAIR presents counterpoints to the theory that the Book of Mormon was derived from The Late War.

2025

Debunking-cesletter.com argues that there is no evidence Joseph Smith came into contact with The First Book of Napoleon.

2025

FAIR argues that the Book of Mormon was not derived from The First Book of Napoleon, shows where CES Letter pulled phrases from.

2025

Mormon Stories perpetuates Captain Kidd-Joseph Smith theories.

2025

Dictionary.com definition of "false cognate."

2025

debunking-cesletter.com argues that the only book available to Joseph Smith about Captain Kidd does not mention a word like Cumorah.

2025

History.com describes schoolteachers in the early 1800s.

2025

Wisdom Library definitions of "Maya" in different Eastern traditions.

2025

Website for Kimnori USA.

2025

Definition of Italian word "camera."

2025

Chemish, Bulgaria, on Google Maps.

2025

Bulbapedia entry for Hearthome City in Pokémon.

2025

Neum, Bosnia and Herzegovina, on Google Maps.

2025

Glosbe translation of Himni from Albanian to English.

2025

SpanishDict definition of pachas.

2025

Shule County, China, on Google Maps.

2025

Blake T. Ostler concludes that Lars Nielsen's How the Book of Mormon Came to Pass is a waste of time and lacks historical evidence.

Apr 2025

Elder David A. Bednar teaches that the Book of Mormon came from God.

Sep 2025

Noaz Cohen et al. find that schizophrenia leads to cognitive decline.

2026

FAIR sums up five Latter-day Saint scholars' criticisms of Grant Palmer's book An Insider's View.

2026

Sarah Allen, writing in FAIR, critiques the CES Letter's comparison of The First Book of Napoleon to the Book of Mormon.

2026

SpanishDict definition of antiparras.