Jeremy Runnells states that in the summer of 2012 "I don't believe in this anymore" on Mormon Stories podcast.
"Mormon Stories 480: Jeremy Runnells Pt 1 - On Growing Up Mormon and the Genesis of the CES Letter," Youtube, June 21, 2014
Jeremy: That was in October of 2012. You have to remember my faith crisis happened in February 2012 and then by that summer of 2012 I was like, "I don't believe in this anymore." So, this happened in October of 2012 so I no longer had a testimony at that time.
38:44 - 39:05